Today I saw this image with the caption on Facebook. The person in the image is Vishnu Shresta, a Gorkha Rifles Jawan. I salute him for his brave act fighting dacoits on September 2, 2012 while traveling on Maurya Express between Kulti and Chittaranjan stations in India.
However, as the days passed by the media distorted the facts. This is one case to show why one should not believe whatever that come across their way in print, absolutely. I do not understand why people try to distort facts to gain readership.
1. How many dacoits were involved?
The Indian Express of September 3, 2010, reported the involvement of 11 dacoits.
According to the eastern railway officials: “A gang of 11 armed dacoits yesterday barged into a compartment of the train at around 11 pm and assaulted the passengers before decamping with cash, a laptop, 33 mobile phones and other valuables.”
However, the following day The Times of India, Calcutta Edition increased the number of dacoits to 30:
Nearly 30 armed dacoits looted cash and valuables worth 10 lakh from passengers of Maurya Express between Kulti and Chittaranjan stations along the West Bengal-Jharkhand border on Thursday night.
On 13th January, 2011 I came across the following in a post published on a website:
A retired Indian Gorkha soldier recently revisited those glory days when he thwarted 40 robbers, killing three of them and injuring eight others, with his khukuri during a train journey
2. Was there an attempt to rape a 18-year-old girl?
On 11th February, 2012, a website wrote:
“After looting the train, when the robbers started to strip a 18-year-old girl in front of him, he couldn’t contain his calmness. He took out his khukari and took on the a group of 30 robbers, alone. In the fight, he killed three of dacoits and injured eight others. Remaining dacoits fled the scene to save their lives.”
The earliest reports that appeared in The Indian Express (September 2, 2010) and The Times of India, Calcutta Edition (September 3, 2010) do not carry reports about any dacoit who attempted to rape an 18-year-old girl. The Times of India reports:
“Suddenly, there were shouts and the sound of running feet,” Shresta recounted from his bed at Kasturba Gandhi Hospital in Chittaranjan. “Somebody pulled at my bedclothes. I sat up and found a number of people standing near my feet. They demanded that I hand over all my cash and valuables. There was confusion all around and I shouted that I am an Indian Army jawan. The criminals backed off and turned their attention to a woman and her child, who were on a berth close by,” Shresta added.
He lost his cool when he saw a miscreant trying to pull out the girl, about 8 years old, from the berth and snatch a necklace from her mother.
The above earliest news reports do not indicate any rape perpetrated on a 18-year-old girl.
3. Were any dacoits killed?
The early news reports in The Indian Express of September 3, 2010 and The Times of India, Calcutta Edition of September 4, 2010 do not mention any dacoits killed. However, the reports that I read on two separate websites xnepali.com on January 16, 2011 and again in OFFICER.com on February 11, 2012, say:
“After looting the train, when the robbers started to strip a 18 year old girl in front of him, he couldn’t contain his calmness. He took out his khukari and took on the a group of 30 robbers, alone. In the fight, he killed three of dacoits and injured eight others. Remaining dacoits fled the scene to save their lives.” (sic)
In fact, the second website OFFICER.com just copied the news from xnepali.com and published the news without even changing a punctuation mark.
- Dacoits loot Maurya Express, 4 passengers injured (indianexpress.com)
- Soldier takes on dacoits on train Gang Of 30 (articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com)
- Lone Nepali Gorkha who subdued 40 train robbers (archives.myrepublica.com)
- A Gurkha soldier, who fought 30 train robbers (xnepali.net)
- A Gurkha soldier, who fought 30 train robbers (forums.officer.com)
- News: A woman gave birth to 11 baby boys in Surat, India. (tvaraj.wordpress.com)
5 thoughts on “Why Do Some Media Distort Facts?”
Indian Media as Usual!! The Best and Worst has only been decided by perspectives and not by facts 😦
Good post. I have also blogged about this, and was also shocked to read the various versions of a robbery that I happened in my building, including in some leading newspapers. Is it carelessness (not bothering to get the facts) or too much use of imagination by the reporters??
They err both ways.